The Boys: Season 4
June 29, 2024
With the trashed audience scores you'd be forgiven for thinking something has changed with The Boys. But the only thing that has changed is the show runner trying to distance himself from a part of his audience for his career.
Here's a Stan Edgar moment. No one wearing a red hat can damage that career. However, those in the entertainment industry unsophisticated enough to believe the show runner wrote this show for "undesirable people" can. So, in that position, you produce the work you always have, reaffirm your support for...whatever, and move on.
This season, Homelander is still trying to cauterise the parts of himself that react to others' disappointment. As he runs on adulation that's not possible. While Homelander sees his emotions as an impairment, Billy Butcher is only able to keep moving because of his cold rage. Butcher has nothing else in his life. If either man was happy there wouldn't be a show. That's always been the show.
Yes, the other characters have stories to tell, but those are just distractions. This is a story about two broken men building up to a merciless showdown. I expect the audience scores to remain in the toilet next season as well but people will watch it because the show itself has not changed. It has exemplary acting and top-notch production value.